Skip to content
Bullishlow conviction · 1 yearActive · reviewed today

Memory is a rent for now: the contracts with price floors outlast this cycle's peak

By MenFem Editorial·NVIDIA·Micron·SK Hynix·Lam Research·Samsung Electronics·Semiconductors — Memory·10 November 2026·Methodology·
ai-infrastructuresemiconductorsmemoryhbmthematic
The next review, the day it is written.
Share

What would prove this wrong · verbatim, as published

The reason for holding this stops being true if the floors do not hold: Micron reporting a GAAP gross margin below 61.0%, its previous cycle record, in any quarter through its fiscal fourth quarter of 2027. It also stops being true if the cycle turns anyway: Micron's revenue falling quarter on quarter for two consecutive quarters in the same period.
  • leg 1 · Floors fail: Micron GAAP gross margin below 61.0% (its 2018 record) in any quarter through FQ4 FY27 · not read yet
  • leg 2 · Cycle turns: Micron revenue down quarter on quarter for two consecutive quarters through FQ4 FY27 · not read yet

The argument, taken apart

Turn it, hover a ring, a moon or a weight
One call, taken apart
Rings are the falsifier’s legs. Moons are the catalysts it named. Weights are its risks, longer for higher severity.
The claim

Micron's revenue is up nearly fivefold in a year at an 87% gross margin, and its contracts carry price floors it says beat any past peak. Bullish on the thesis at low conviction: the floors hold margins above the old…

What would make it wrong · 2 legs
  1. Leg 1 · Not read yet
    Floors fail: Micron GAAP gross margin below 61.0% (its 2018 record) in any quarter through FQ4 FY27
    Not read at a review yet.
  2. Leg 2 · Not read yet
    Cycle turns: Micron revenue down quarter on quarter for two consecutive quarters through FQ4 FY27
    Not read at a review yet.
The window
10 Nov 2026 to 10 Nov 2027
0% gone · 364 days left
The reviews
Not reviewed since it was published
  • Leg 1, not read yet: Floors fail: Micron GAAP gross margin below 61.0% (its 2018 record) in any quarter through FQ4 FY27
  • Leg 2, not read yet: Cycle turns: Micron revenue down quarter on quarter for two consecutive quarters through FQ4 FY27
  • Micron FQ1 FY27 results (Dec 2026)
  • New memory capacity (CXMT, Korean and US fabs)
  • high severity: Record margins invite supply
  • high severity: Floors are untested
  • medium severity: One company as the gauge

The timeline · 1 entry · newest firstreviews · notes · moves · the book

  1. 10 Nov 2026
    Opened

    Memory is a rent for now: the contracts with price floors outlast this cycle's peak

Key Points

  • Micron FQ4 FY26: revenue $54.2B (from $11.3B a year earlier); GAAP gross margin 86.8% (from 44.7%).
  • FQ1 FY27 guide: $61.5B at ~86% gross margin.
  • Micron 10-K: most strategic agreements priced in bands; floor-price margins 'meaningfully above' any past peak.
  • Previous record: 61.0% GAAP gross margin (FQ4 2018).

Memory has always been a cycle: shortages push prices and margins to a peak, makers build, and prices fall. AI has pushed this one further than any before. Micron's quarter to early September 2026 brought revenue of $54.2B, against $11.3B a year earlier, at a GAAP gross margin of 86.8%, against 44.7%, and it guided the next quarter to $61.5B at about 86%. Its previous record, at the last memory peak in 2018, was 61.0%. SK hynix is reported to have its HBM sold out years ahead, and price trackers report conventional DRAM contract prices still rising. What is new is how the memory is sold. Micron's 2026 annual report says most of its strategic customer agreements are multi-year, take-or-pay, backed by customer deposits, and priced within minimum and maximum bands, and that gross margins at the floor prices would be meaningfully above its peak quarterly margins in any past cycle. The claim here is that this holds: through Micron's fiscal 2027 its gross margin stays above the old 61% record, because the floors bind before the cycle does. That supports MenFem's bullish SK Hynix, Micron and Samsung calls, and it is bad news for MenFem's calls that inference gets much cheaper, since memory is the input getting dearer. Conviction is LOW. These are the highest margins memory has ever earned, and the usual answer to record margins is new supply: Chinese makers such as CXMT are adding capacity, and memory shares reportedly fell between about 11% and 26% in five days in mid-October on fears of oversupply by 2029. Micron itself says the contract structure still subjects it to risk, and a floor is only as good as a customer's willingness to honour it in a glut. BULLISH on the thesis, conviction LOW, one year. This view was formed by MenFem's research process at Connor's request and adopted by him.

Bull Case

AI demand keeps HBM and server DRAM short through 2027, the band contracts lock in prices, and Micron's margin stays far above any past peak while capacity takes years to arrive.

Bear Case

What I'd have to believe for the other side: every memory peak has looked structural at the time. An 87% gross margin on a commodity is the strongest signal to build there is, and contracts signed at the top get renegotiated at the bottom.

Catalysts

Micron FQ1 FY27 results (Dec 2026)Earnings

Revenue against $61.5B and gross margin against ~86%.

New memory capacity (CXMT, Korean and US fabs)Other

Supply that would test the price floors.

Risk factors

Record margins invite supplyHigh

New fabs and Chinese makers aim at the most profitable memory market ever.

Floors are untestedHigh

Price bands have not been through a glut; customers may renegotiate.

One company as the gaugeMedium

The test reads Micron's filings; SK hynix and Samsung may differ.

Related Calls

LONGActive

Optics takes the new links, copper keeps the short ones: both grow through 2027

Co-packaged optics is arriving on schedule while copper cables inside the rack keep growing. Bullish on the thesis at medium conviction: the rack is big enough for both through 2027, and neither side's story of taking the other's place holds yet.

Coherent PhotonLink (CPO/NPO): >$100M in the March 2027 quarter, $250M a quarter before end-2027 (4 Nov slides).

Lumentum: >$5B of CPO/NPO commitments; Marvell to buy Lumentum (all-stock, ~$115B, 2 Nov), citing copper's limits.

ai-infrastructuresemiconductorsoptics
NVIDIABroadcomAstera LabsCoherent CorpCredo TechnologyLumentumMarvell TechnologyArista Networks
LONGActive

The old GPUs get cheap first: H100 rents fall as the new chips arrive, the newest hold

Every new NVIDIA generation pushes the last one down the price curve. Bullish on the thesis at low conviction: H100 rents fall over the next year while the newest chips hold, which hurts renters with spot exposure and spares those on contract.

MenFem vast.ai offers, four-week averages to 6 Nov: H100 SXM $2.38/hr (from $2.97 on 25 Sep); B200 $9.69/hr (from $9.38).

Azure list: H100 SXM spot $2.27 vs on-demand $12.29; unchanged for six weeks.

ai-infrastructurecompute-pricinggpu
NVIDIAOracleCoreWeaveNebius GroupCore ScientificIREN
LONGActive

Custom chips take share and NVIDIA keeps growing: the pie is bigger than the fight

Hyperscalers' own chips are growing about twice as fast as NVIDIA's data-centre business, from a fifth of its size. Bullish on the thesis: custom silicon gains share without denting NVIDIA's growth or margin, for now.

Broadcom AI semiconductor revenue $16.7B (+221%); next-quarter guide $21.7B; backlog $179.2B.

NVIDIA data-centre revenue $89.0B (+117%); gross margin 75.0% (from 72.4%); hyperscale customers +102%.

ai-infrastructuresemiconductorscustom-silicon
NVIDIAMicrosoftBroadcomAlphabetAmazon (AWS)Meta PlatformsMarvell Technology